Let me contribute 4 lists with my top 5 entries in each of them (although not too specific in cases). Most of these guitars are discussed above so in that sense nothing new gets added. But thematically there is quite a difference as well as in money and effort involved. So here goes:
"Everyday Rarities" (pre-BBE):
- Broadcaster
- ASAT III, either S-500 or Skyhawk pups
- G-200
- hog S-500 or even rarer maple S-500.
- SC-1
Numbers 1, 2, and 5 all have a maple body making them sound exceptional. The G-200 is the best sounding double humbucker guitar nobody knows about.
"Everyday Rarities" (BBE):
- Z-2
- ASAT '50
- 20th Anniversary
- Trinity
- ASAT JD-5
Three out of the 5 are due to the efforts of Mr Tim Page. Honorable mention: the ASAT Super.
"Artist guitars"
- Any of John Jorgensen G&L's, e.g. his Z-coil prototype.
- Any of Will Ray's ASAT's, e.g. his non-flake turquoise ASAT with the Hipshot on it.
- Any of Jake Cinningers S-500 and Comanche guitars
- Any of Guitar Shorty's guitars (there is currently one on eBay which allegedly belonged to him).
- Some Nashville gun slingers' ASAT they wouldn't play on stage but use in the studio. There are plenty of musicians over there for whom their trusty G&L ASAT or SC-2 is their guilty pleasure nobody knows about.
Remember that the most popular, collectible models nowadays are those that were played by the music heroes in the '60s. So maybe it can happen with G&L too ... OK, clearly I'm dreaming now ...
"For collectors (No! Don't touch it! You can hear the sustain go on and on ...)"
- "The Rembrandt"
- Any of the 3 "Buck Owens" ASAT Classics.
- Any of the 7 Lacewood Leo Fender Commemorative ASAT Classics.
- Any of the 15 or so October 1991 double- and triple-bound ASAT Classics.
- Any of the instruments previously owned by George Fullerton (see his "Guitar Legends" book); many have gold hardware.
Finding one of these is extremely hard. Maybe I should say "was extremely hard" in my case, but still. Here honorable mention goes to the X-body Interceptor specifically with Cavalier pups. Like Ken, I have never played one, but they sure are hard to find. Second honorable mention goes to some notable test mules/prototypes; a couple are features in the gallery (S-300, T-400).
- Jos