I always cringe when a guitarist wants to try my bass. It's not so bad when I'm playing the upright - they attempt about three notes and then pass it back because their fingers hurt - but when it's an electric I know I'll be in for atonal and busy, with no hint of a downbeat. Lead guitarists are the worst, as they usually have the mindset (IMHO) of playing
over the chord changes instead of
through the changes.
I do think Darwin's statement is very true from another perspective: a good bassist should really know his or her stuff on rhythm guitar. The dexterity and technical skills may not be there, but there should be a strong understanding of how the song's chords fit together and how to go smoothly from one to the next. If a bassist isn't completely at home inside of the chords (including an instinctive feel for passing tones), he won't be able to do a good job of tying the changes together and moving the song forward.
I'd also suggest here that "too many notes" or fast playing isn't necessarily a bad thing. It all depends on the song and what the other players are doing at the moment. My personal rule of thumb is to do the opposite of the guitar player (especially the rhythm guitarist in a four- or five-piece combo). If he goes up high, I head for the bottom. Fast licks are going to get sustained bass notes under them, and sustained chords are probably going to get a quarter-note walking line tying them together. I once banned a rhythm guitarist from going below the seventh fret on hard rock songs and blues numbers - he was just muddying the mix up too much for me to do anything besides doubling his root notes.
Dick Seacup wrote:Oh man! When I was downtown with said 7yo son for his drum lesson last night, there was a high school kid playing his bass (unplugged) in the lobby. He was good, but I kept thinking, "Playing that many notes, that far up the neck is just going to get lost in the mix." Maybe he was a guitar player!
My 7 y/o is totally in love with his bass. This afternoon I caught him playing the intro to "Some Day We'll be Together" after he finished his homework. I'm still a bit baffled that he figured it out from memory, and in the correct key (A flat). I know I'm veering off-topic, but cut a proud dad some slack, OK?
Ken